•
1 10

THE NATALIE HOLDEN LETTERS - OCRACOKE, NC

THE NATALIE HOLDEN LETTERS - OCRACOKE, NC(PREPAID)

A Yearlong Mystery Experience You Won’t Find Anywhere Else
  • First Mailing: December 5, 2025
  • 24 Immersive Letters, Delivered Twice per Month
  • Includes postcards, recipes, maps, diary entries, and more!
  • 2 limited-edition, numbered 4x6 watercolor prints ($30 value - prepaid orders only)
  • FREE Postage in the USA ($20 value)

NOTE: The monthly payment option is not available at this time.

** Prepaid payment spots remaining: 45

  • Free Shipping
  • 30-Day Money Back Guarantee
  • 100% Delivery Guarantee
"I LOVED this. I felt like I was right there visiting Ocracoke Island. We stayed at an Inn there a few years ago, so this was perfect."
- Anne W. - Early Reader
View full details

OUR PROMISE

  • Money-Back Guarantee

    We created The Moonlit Letters to be an enjoyable experience, one that draws you into each mystery collection and keeps you fully immersed. We want our stories to be a positive experience for you, and we fully stand behind the service we provide. If you’re not completely satisfied after receiving your first two letters, simply let us know within 30 days of your first mailing. We’ll issue you a full refund, no questions asked.

  • Delivery Guarantee

    Each letter contains vital pieces of the mystery you will solve, so it’s important to us that you get them in the intended order. If a letter ever gets lost or damaged in the mail, let us know. We’ll send a free replacement right away at no extra cost to you. Email us with your order number, and we’ll take care of the rest.

  • Giving as a Gift?

    Click here to access a printable or digital gift introduction, perfect to share with your loved ones to let them know that something special is on its way to their mailboxes.

    For step-by-step instructions on how to place a gift order, see the FAQ section below.

WHAT READERS ARE SAYING

"I LOVED this. I felt like I was right there visiting Ocracoke Island. We stayed at an Inn there a few years ago, so this was perfect."
- Anne W. - Early Reader
"I had a great time reading the letters of Natalie Holden as she worked to uncover a decades-old mystery on Ocracoke Island. Natalie’s voice is so distinct. I could picture her and the village so clearly, as well as the colorful cast of characters. The addition of puzzles and recipes made this a fun interactive experience. This mystery kept me guessing from the beginning to the end of her letters. I can’t wait to read about Natalie’s next case!"
- Erin C. - Early Reader
"To be honest I have never heard of a service like this before. I grew up watching and reading mysteries so I had to try it out. The story I read was captivating. It gave plenty of background information without being too wordy and every time there was a picture or activity, I instantly had to do it. I think that anyone who loves mysteries, or is even just a book lover could appreciate and love it! This could totally be a great gift for someone too. 10/10"
- Katharine W. - Early Reader
"I loved the premise, and it really felt like a collaboration in solving the mystery. The entire experience was like being part of an Aurora Teagarden mystery mixed together with an episode of Murder She Wrote on Cabot Cove. As a frequent traveler to Tybee Island, GA, the entire mystery had a ring of truth/realistic feel about it. I think the attention to detail made the entire experience feel realistic, and I truthfully loved it."
- Charlotte G. - Early Reader
"I liked the references to the small town environment – took me to another place I’ve never visited. The back and forth from past events to present events was an interesting storytelling technique. I also found the presentation of photos, postcards, letters etc. to be a delightful way to present the story"
- Winni L. - Early Reader

Customer Reviews

Frequently Asked Questions

How does it work?

When you subscribe to The Moonlit Letters, you will receive 24 envelopes over the course of one year (two envelopes per month). This unique story experience unfolds through letters, diary entries, and other forms of correspondence between characters.

When will I receive my first letter?

Your first letter ships within 3 business days of your order, with USPS tracking for US orders. Most US subscribers receive it within 5-8 business days. The remaining letters are sent via regular mail every other Friday of each month.

What if I subscribe after the story has started?

Don’t worry, everyone starts with Letter #1. So, no matter when you subscribe, you’ll be able to follow the story from the very beginning.

Do you ship internationally?

Yes! We ship worldwide. International mail may take up to 6 weeks, depending on your country’s postal system. All letters are sent via standard mail.

Can I give this service as a gift?

Absolutely! Be sure to follow these steps when checking out:

  1. Select the story you’d like to send (available as a prepaid or monthly subscription), and add it to your cart.
  2. Put the word "gift" in the "Order special instructions" box in your cart.
  3. Enter your recipient’s mailing address at checkout. If you are sending to more than one person, simply complete your first order. Then, place a new order for each additional recipient.
  4. Enter your own billing details at checkout. All payment confirmations and receipts will be sent to the email you provide. After you have completed your purchase, we will send you a confirmation email.
  5. Want to let your loved one know their gift is on the way? Click here to download a printable or digital introduction you can give or email right away.

What’s inside each letter?

Each envelope holds pieces of the story. You’ll read personal letters between characters and diary entries. There are also vintage-style maps, postcards, newspaper clippings, recipes, puzzles, and much more.

Are the stories appropriate for all ages?

We write the stories with adult readers in mind. However, they are wholesome and family-friendly. Readers who enjoy wholesome mysteries (with a little suspense mixed in) will feel right at home.

What happens when the story ends?

Once you receive all 24 envelopes, your experience is complete. If you’re craving more immersive mystery stories, you may sign up for another one of our collections (a new one is always in the works). As a current subscriber, you’ll get early access to future stories.

Still have questions?

Please reach out to us by clicking here. We’ll get back to you as soon as we can.