Skip to product information
1 of 11

Natalie Holden Monthly Mysteries

Natalie Holden Monthly Mysteries

A Solvable Monthly Mystery You Won’t Find Anywhere Else

MAILING SOON: The Case of the Death Stairs (A Natalie Holden Monthly Mystery #2) - Takes place in Savannah, GA.

Become a member, and each month's mailing will include:

• One long letter from Natalie: Immerse yourself in a mystery set in a fascinating place.
• Natalie's Notes: Review the suspects and learn more about the case.
• One postcard: Enjoy a unique postcard from each month’s locale. The postcards are suitable for mailing to family and friends.
• One art print: Collect Natalie’s artwork, one-of-a-kind pieces featuring sights and objects she encounters during her travels.
• Extra inserts: Some months you will find surprise extras that will pull you deeper into the setting and the mystery.
• Premium stationery: Savor the tactile experience of reading each month’s letter on premium paper.Look forward to a rotating collection of high-end envelopes and paper stocks.
• Sealed solution: Unseal a small envelope to learn the truth.
• A chance to interact with a community of sleuths: Join our community to discuss the case and trade theories with fellow readers.

Includes FREE Postage in the USA

Note: This is a month-to-month subscription. Once you subscribe, you will immediately be charged for your first mystery, using your chosen payment method. After that, you’ll be billed on the first day of each month. For more info, see the "How does billing work" section in the FAQ below.

CASE #2 CLOSES ON NOVEMBER 20th AT 11:59PM

Looking for a past case? Click Here.

Regular price $12.99 USD
Regular price Sale price $12.99 USD
Sale Sold out
Shipping calculated at checkout.
  • Free Shipping in the USA
  • 100% Delivery Guarantee
"These mysteries are such a fun and entertaining escape, and I love having a new one waiting for me in the mailbox. It’s a great way to step away from the everyday for a little while, especially when most days the mail is nothing but bills and junk. Each installment feels like a small surprise to look forward to!"
- Katharen M. - Beta Reader

Mailing Schedule

Order on or before November 20th and you will receive Case #2, which will begin mailing during the first full week of November 2026.

Please allow up to 2 weeks for delivery in the US.

All future monthly cases will mail out during the first full week of the month.

View full details
  • Delivery Guarantee:

    If a letter ever gets lost or damaged in the mail, let us know. We’ll send a free replacement right away at no extra cost to you. Email us with your order number, and we’ll take care of the rest.

"These mysteries are such a fun and entertaining escape, and I love having a new one waiting for me in the mailbox."
- Katharen M. - Early Reader

WHAT READERS ARE SAYING:

Frequently Asked Questions

Which issue will I begin with when signing up?

Each mystery is only available for that particular month.

If you sign up on or before the twentieth of the month, you will receive the current mystery.

If you sign up after the twentieth, you will be sent the next mystery when it’s released (during the first full week of the following month).

After that, you will receive all future mysteries as long as you are subscribed.

Past mysteries may become available in the future if we have leftover copies. These will be offered on a first-come, first-served basis.

When will I receive my first mystery?

US customers can expect the first mystery to be delivered about two weeks after it’s mailed. Future mysteries will be mailed during the first full week of every month as long as your subscription is active.

How does billing work?

Once you subscribe, you will immediately be charged for your first mystery, using your chosen payment method. After that, you’ll be billed on the first day of each month.

If you sign up on or before the twentieth, your second charge would occur on the first day of the following month. Example: Sign up on January 19th. The initial charge to your account will be made that day and your first mystery mailed out ASAP. Your will next be charged February 1st, when your second mystery is being prepared for mailing.

If you sign up after the twentieth, your account will be charged upon activation of your subscription and then again on the first day of the month after the following month. Example: Sign up on January 21st. Payment is made that day, and your first mystery is mailed out during the first full week of February. You will next be charged on March 1st when your second mystery is being prepped for mailing.

Do you ship internationally?

Currently, the Natalie Holden Monthly Mysteries are only available to readers in the USA.

Can I give this service as a gift?

Absolutely!

We have two pre-paid subscription options available:

6-Month Pre-Paid

12-Month Pre-Paid (Get 1 month FREE)

Be sure to follow these steps when checking out:

  1. Add the 6-Month or 12-Month pre-paid subscription to your shopping cart.
  2. Put the word "gift" in the "Order special instructions" box in your cart.
  3. Enter your recipient’s mailing address at checkout. If you are sending to more than one person, simply complete your first order. Then, place a new order for each additional recipient.
  4. Enter your own billing details at checkout. All payment confirmations and receipts will be sent to the email you provide. After you have completed your purchase, we will send you a confirmation email.
  5. Want to let your loved one know their gift is on the way? Click here to download a Gifting Card you can print, fold, and give right away. There are cards for the 6-month subscription and the 12-month subscription, to let them know how long they can expect to receive mysteries in the mail.

Are the letters appropriate for all ages?

Though these letters do not contain any explicit language or sexual content, many of the cases involve violent crimes such as murder. Therefore, these letters are recommended for adult readers only.

Are these letters real?

Each letter depicts a crime that is entirely fictitious. However, the cities and towns that Natalie visits are real places with real landmarks, although we fictionalize all the businesses and people that she interacts with.

Still have questions?

Please reach out to us by clicking here. We’ll get back to you as soon as we can.

IMPORTANT: If you don't hear from us within 48 hours, please be sure to check your spam/junk folders.